Freshly Made. Grandma Approved.
Lots of people say our pies taste like the ones their grandma made. Well, that’s because our recipes come straight from the weathered cookbooks of our founders’ grandmothers, Ruth and Edith. Enjoy the fresh baked goodness and all the good feelings that only homemade pies can deliver.
Freshly Made. Grandma Approved.
Lots of people say our pies taste like the ones their grandma made. Well, that’s because our recipes come straight from the weathered cookbooks of our founders’ grandmothers, Ruth and Edith. Enjoy the fresh baked goodness and all the good feelings that only homemade pies can deliver.
From Our Kitchen to Your Table
As you browse our pies below, keep in mind that availability varies by location and season. Don’t worry if the shop near you doesn’t have what you’re looking for- we can ship it to you faster than a hot knife through butter.
Use our pie-finding filter to sort through our menu, then check local availability HERE to see if they’re at a shop near you.
Always Available
SOUTHERN CUSTARD
Smooth, mild & sweet, our buttermilk filling is a cross between our Chess pie and a sugar cookie. Yum!
Always Available
GRANNY’S APPLE
This pie tastes like sweet tradition. Sliced apples meet sugar & spice—all under a brown sugar topping.
Always Available
PEANUT BUTTER CREAM
A rich filling of whipped peanut butter & cream cheese set in an Oreo crust. The best PB cup you’ve ever had.
Always Available
KEY LIME
A dreamy key lime filling in our graham cracker crust. One bite, and you’ll hear the ocean’s call.
Always Available
I-40
Named for Interstate 40, this twist on Pecan Pie connects us all. Topped with shredded coconut & chocolate chips.
Seasonal Feature
NANNY’S PECAN
The perfect blend of toasted pecans & gooey filling spread into a buttery crust. A Southern favorite!
Seasonal Feature
STRAWBERRY
Like the potluck favorite, but prettier! Our sweet strawberry filling, crowned with cream cheese whip.
Seasonal Feature
LEMON ICE BOX
A sunny, citrus filling in our graham cracker crust. Tangy. Sweet. Refreshing. Need we say more?
Seasonal Feature
CHERRY
Sweet & tart cherries, baked until bubbly and topped with a buttery crumble. Great alone or à la mode!
Seasonal Feature
SPICED PUMPKIN
A sweet & creamy spiced pumpkin filling. Topped with a shortbread pumpkin to complete your holiday table.
Seasonal Feature
CARAMEL TURTLE
An insanely delicious combo of chocolate, caramel & pecans. Think Chocolate Chess, with a sweet crunch!
Seasonal Feature
BLUEBERRY
Brimming with blueberries picked at their prime & perfectly sweetened. A must-have for any picnic!
Pineapple Delight
Our version of a family reunion favorite: Whipped pineapple cream & pecans in our signature graham cracker crust.
SPICED APPLE CUSTARD
A delicious twist on apple pie—Apple butter and seasonal spices are baked into a custard and topped with spiced cream cheese whip.
Blackberry Custard
Plump blackberries meet scrumptious custard filling. A fruity twist that’s the best of both worlds!
FRENCH SILK
Craving chocolate mousse? Sink your teeth into this rich, velvety chocolate filling whipped to silky perfection.
CHOCOLATE CHESS
This rich, chocolatey pie lives at the corner of fudge and custard. Perfectly baked to a crusty crackle.
CHOCOLATE CREAM
Chocolate lovers, line up for our rich, chocolate custard in an Oreo crust. It’s ultimate cocoa bliss.
CHEWY CHOCOLATE CHIP
Starring a timeless trio of brown sugar, chocolate chips & vanilla—this gooey pie’s made for cookie lovers!
SNICKERDOODLE
Cinnamon & sugar make this buttery pie. So close to a cinnamon roll, you can serve it for breakfast!
CARAMEL
A take on butterscotch pie from the good ol’ days. Slow-cooked caramel topped with toasted meringue.
LEMON MERINGUE
Pucker up for this tart treat! Lemons are baked into our crust & topped with sweet peaks of meringue.
CRANBERRY WALNUT
A sweet, nutty pairing of cranberries & walnuts with a hint of orange zest. This pie’s made for cozy season.
GRANDDADDY’S SWEET POTATO
Savor the holiday sweetness! Dive into our sweet potato filling topped with ginger whip & candied pecans.
COCONUT CREAM
Rich, creamy coconut custard topped with baked meringue. Voted “Best of” by Taste of the South magazine.
S’MORES
Gather ‘round for this fudgy brownie filling in a graham cracker crust. Marshmallow-y goodness on top!
TRIPLE BERRY
Blueberries, blackberries & strawberries topped with a buttery crumble and bursting with flavor. Berry delish!
PEACH
Cherish summer flavors with juicy peaches tossed in brown sugar & cinnamon. Topped with a buttery crumble.
CHOCOLATE I D’ECLAIR
The famous French pastry, pie-ified! Sweet vanilla custard, velvety chocolate ganache & chocolate whip.
BANANA CREAM
You’ll go bananas for this filling. It’s like bananas foster & pudding combined with every sublime bite!
CHOCOLATE MERINGUE
A decadent & delicious Southern classic. Slow-cooked chocolate custard topped with luscious meringue.
Getting Sweets is Easy as Pie.
Have Questions About Our Pies?
Click here for the most common questions and answers.