Steve & Natasha Cox with their family


845 FM 548
Suite 100
Forney, TX 75126

Phone: (972) 564-8003

Monday – Thursday: 10am – 7pm

Friday – Saturday: 10am – 8pm



Want a free pie?

We believe when you share pie, you share love.

We want to share pie with you! Join our PIE PERKS Club! We'll send you news on seasonal offerings and special PIE PERKS deals, including a FREE 4-inch pie (with purchase of any 4" or 9" pie) on your birthday. That's a lot of love!

Meet Our Owners

Natasha Cox holding a Smores Pie

Steve & Natasha Cox, Owners
Opened Shop: February 2020

Steve & Natasha Cox opened the pie shop in February 2020. 

Steve & Natasha moved to Forney in 1999 because it had that small town feel and they knew this was where they wanted to raise their family. They have 3 amazing children, Audrey, Emma & Joshua, who have all grown up in Forney.  
The first time they tried a pie from Buttermilk Sky Pie, they knew they had just had the best pie ever and not long after, with much prayer, they decided to open a Buttermilk Sky Pie of their own. They knew that opening a pie shop would be their way of giving back and be able to bless others in their community, especially with the Pie It Forward program in place they could give back to nonprofit organizations and serve great pie at the same time! 
Steve’s favorite pie is by far the Key Lime Pie and Natasha’s favorite is the Banana Cream, Cherry, Peach, Coconut, Chocolate, well the list goes on & on. It’s hard to narrow it down to just one pie. Oh, and that crust-WOW!!!  
Their motto is to treat others how you would want to be treated and for each customer to be treated as if they were family as soon as they walk in our shop. 

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop